Openhab vs home assistant reddit. Perfect to run on a Raspberry Pi or a local server.

Openhab vs home assistant reddit. Has all the integrations I need. openhab. 2. Home Assistant. OpenHAB, known for its robust Java-based framework, excels in providing a versatile system that supports a wide array of protocols and devices. 5 is the latest version available having emerged from the ancient version in 2010 by Kai Kreuzer. I've tagged all my items to use in Alexa, Google Assistant and homekit. conf files. Mar 26, 2024 · OpenHAB et Home Assistant sont tous deux des systèmes de domotique open source, offrant une large gamme de fonctionnalités pour contrôler et automatiser les appareils de votre maison. . com panel. So basically I could control my devices and home security through alarm. It supports various protocols such as Zigbee, Z-Wave, Bluetooth, and HomeKit, making it a versatile platform for device integration. I wonder how people with Home Assistant deal with their non-techie spouses and family, since every update or change in an integration has the potential to break stuff which then takes (down)time to fix. Ils prennent en charge de nombreux protocoles de communication et offrent une grande flexibilité dans la configuration et l’intégration avec des appareils View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. In OH3, I noticed that there is a set of widget/rule/etc. 1 Like. I have tried both, in my opinion OpenHAB is better, I believe you can achieve the same in the end. You are right about setup costs vs control, but I'm not entirely sure if this is a home assistant issue. The customisable UI, the fact that there's an App for notifications, and having a VSCode extension definitely piques my interest. When it comes to the development and design features of the two, there is a notable difference. Jun 10, 2024 · OpenHAB vs Home Assistant. Dec 13, 2023 · My assessment, after reading a lot, is that the home assistant is sufficient for simple smart home setups with around 100 items and a handful of technologies. I tried Home Assistant, but they could never transfer the locks from the Home Assistant to the alarm. Home Assistant Container - Docker image of Home Assistant Jun 6, 2020 · Home Assistant Vs OpenHAB: Creation and Architecture. Sep 10, 2022 · I don’t want to stir any debate but I realized that in some of the more recent HomeAssistant versions, they have a native support for scenes. Hi all, I’m using openhab for many years now. When adding a device to openHAB, you can install various Bindings, either officially or community Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. That being said, here are the options that I found for HA/Goole Assistant integration. Concerning the App: the OpenHab Android app supports sending the current alarm settings to your OpenHab installation, which can be a awesome feature. Available for free at home-assistant. With Home Assistant you have to pay monthly usd$6. I'm fairly technically capable, Linux is my favourite OS, I play with r-pi's a fair amount and I code in various languages - these days mostly code Python with a little C++. And the advanced scenes and rules would be handled through my Vera I didn't really care about the stability of my Vera. So, that is the same process as moving to HA. What is Hubitat? Hubitat is a smart home platform that allows users to add devices such as lights, thermostats, sensors, etc, and connect them to a centralized hub (Hubitat) . This distinguishes OpenHAB and Home Assistant. Home Assistant OS - available as a virtual machine image with Home Assistant preinstalled. Here we get it for free. Been waiting to see something like this for a long time to unify different equipment around the house. In my humble opinion both OpenHab and HomeAssisntat have their “positives and negatives”. Mar 5, 2022 · But as mentioned above please consider donating to the foundation which buys the hardware to host the cloud and pay for running costs and more. io. Also being active in both respective forums I see people migrate both directions some come here because for any reason they can’t work with Home Assistant and vice versa. People are now making their own open-source programs for their smart home hubs. 5 with about 170 things and many rules, and some of them rather complicated. For alexa and google home you need to configure a connection to the free openhab cloud. A place to share and discuss all things related to home automation. I bought a 3090 last week for Machine learning purposes. 50 fees and can not do it for a full year unless you live in the USA. OpenHAB and Home Assistants are two of the biggest names in open-source automation. And now I am turning to local LLMs and HeyWillow. I am a home assistant user. OpenHab and VeraPlus both support cameras but in my usage of these platforms was mediocre at best. I know the open source ones such as OpenHAB and Home Assistant are far more difficult to setup and require extra hardware but as a programmer, that doesn't worry me. The learning curve is a bit steeper then home assistent, but in the end you realise a lot of thing is a lot easier in OpenHAB. Home Assistant also has zwave lock support now, which OpenHAB is still lacking (it's in beta though). Oct 8, 2023 · I’m using openHAB since 12 years now and been through a lot with it. com app. Jan 31, 2024 · Smart home enthusiasts often find themselves comparing OpenHAB and Home Assistant—two of the leading platforms in home automation. 238K subscribers in the homeassistant community. OpenHAB is much easier to understand if you have programming experience. 6 days ago · Are you trying to choose the best home automation platform for your needs? Then this page is for you. Powered by… Hubitat really hits the sweet spot for me between SmartThings and Home Assistant, and all the weird/complicated automations I'd been trying to ST to do, HE was right there for (I'm particularly proud of how I've tied 4 different supplemental heating systems to the ecobee's operating mode, temperature set point, and current status). However, there is a niche group like Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. So you'd just need to make the relevant API call to your instance of OpenHab for whatever voice trigger you set. Dec 21, 2023 · Should I upgrade to openHAB 4 or move to Home Assistant? I am currently on OH 2. I use Hassio (HA) in docker, on Intel i3 Nuc, running Linux Mint. Kinda love it, some things are more straightforward there than they seem to be with Home Assistant - some things are tedious. Updates are managed via the Home Assistant’s web interface and can be easily installed via mouse swipe. Try googling this and only looking for results in the past 2 years May 19, 2024 · Recommendation: Home Assistant vs OpenHab What Is Best No doubt that both of the platforms come with numerous benefits but it all boils down to the user interface for the absolute beginners and the customization options for the ones that want to go the extra mile even if the learning curve seems steeper for them. I don't know much about the Echo, but with Google Home you can use IFTTT to create recipes linking Google Assistant to a web request using the Maker channel. Dec 27, 2023 · I find it quite amusing that HA (that is written in Python) is more qumbersome than openHAB (written in java) wrt writing rules in Python (via habapp). openHAB and Home Assistant both support tons of different smart home devices and since they’re both Z-wave and Zigbee compatible, there are thousands of different devices that can be added to both. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. If you do need a GUI for scripting Home Assistant, simply export the signals you need on MQTT and use Node Red. Homekit is by far the most usefull one - cause the Apple Home app is best in class. Apr 6, 2023 · Integrations – openHAB vs. I have no experience with Home Assistant but I've been using Homeseer for YEARS and it can do ALMOST everything I want. json/. but the main 2 that are suggested is OpenHAB and home assistant. When reading comments, it seems best not to upgrade from 2. openHAB actually looks pretty damn decent. Several years of runtime without any crashes or major errors. Configuration that ends up in . Everytime you have to do anything in home assistant you are going to need at least 30 lines of yaml. Eh, the release notes are of varying quality. My biggest problem with Homeseer is digging through the forums to find the answers I need. You can also quickly achieve satisfactory results. I used Hubitat until home assistant finally fix it. Right now I would say home assistant, I have been using openhab for 2 years. HA seems to be winning new users Home Assistant (HA) user here. I’d like to have a deeper look into Home Assistant so I: installed Home Assistant OS on a NUC got some of my devices into Home Assistant and I can see them and play around with them. Home Assistant is quite a bit prettier and is more noob friendly. Home assistant works with Nest products Home assistant or OpenHAB Looking to start creating my own smart home and have narrowed down to HA or OHAB. You can use Home Assistant cloud. Home Assistant vs Openhab 2 I've been running Openhab 1 for a few years now and decided to upgrade to openhab 2 (OH2). An Android app is currently being developed. Feb 28, 2018 · OpenHAB and Home Assistant are two best open source smart home hubs. And I have learned to hate java thru the years… As I probably have became a grumpy old man, I DO really like configuration in . All of my friends are using HA. I also tried out Home Assistant a couple of years ago but really hated the UI and the fact that you have to reload everything if you add new devices. Since open-source things tend to go better the more popular they are, I'm leaning towards HA, but I'd like to hear from openHAB fans on why they think it's better. For example, Home Assistant's integration with tp-link was horrendous with constant offline problems. Habituat has a higher chance of going belly up than Home Assistant simply because of the number of developers that contribute to Home Assistant. Home Assistant is also great, but has a different focus. io to control my house. Home Assistant has an official iOS app that has existed for a while. Open Home Automation Bus (openHAB), started in 2010, is an open-source home automation that runs in Java. The downside is that the Home Assistant cloud costs $5/month. One of the advantages of Openhab is its flexibility in integrating devices. Plus, if you ever need to extend things? stick with Home Assistant. Home Assistant itself as well as any add-ons you install will run as containers in the VM, but this all happens transparently and you don't necessarily need to know about docker to use this method. From my Point of View, openhab ist much better in configuration of UIs. I installed MarryTTS and PicoTTS (Only need one but I got both) in docker to give me local text-to-speech (no going to cloud to have my system verbally say things). But I really think to move to Home Assistant, because of the bigger Community and more ‘easy to use’ addons and more bindings. With 2 ESP32-S3-BOX set and two more on the way to replace the 16 Google minis, getting rid of google sure is getting expensive. r/homeassistant • The Unity sensor uses the LD2410 and ESPHome to provide human presence detection in Home Assistant. With openHAB, things are a bit more complicated as these are done via a command line. Perfect to run on a Raspberry Pi or a local server. This is likely the simplest way. Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Today I want to compare three of the main platforms out there, OpenHab vs Home Assistant vs Domoticz. I use it to turn my lights on gradually before the alarm sounds. To start with, OpenHAB 2. 3M subscribers in the homeautomation community. to manage scenes in OH but this doesn’t look as easy to configure as the scenes in Jan 18, 2020 · Disclaimer: By writing this post, my intent is not to be little one platform VS the other. Home assistant has devs who's full time job it is to work on home assistant. 1. Having some Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. But when comparing the OpenHAB vs Home Assistant programs, which is better for your home?The main difference between OpenHAB and Home Assistant is that Home Assistant is slightly better rated for its user-friendly build and yes, built-in. On a Pi it takes ages to start up and isn't very responsive even after that. The reality is that the amount of flexibility that it affords combine with its pace of development means that there is a very steep initial learning curve, that is more akin to climbing a cliff. It seems like Home Assistant has a huge community and tons of video walkthroughs that should make learning easier. org), to ask questions related to setup & configuration, post demos and examples of their own solutions, and discuss features, home automation equipment and other openHAB/HA related topics. Both platforms showed impressive offering, with OpenHAB being more mature and stable, while Looking to start creating my own smart home and have narrowed down to HA or OHAB. As I understand it, openHAB came first, but now seems to be less popular than Home Assistant. One thing that has me wondering is the support, large community and ease of use of the commercial hubs (SmartThings, HomeSeer, etc) outweigh the flexibility and lower cost of the We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Both openHAB and Home Assistant can also be installed via Docker. openHAB Foundation. Here is my take openhab: some say it has a steep learning curve, but if you have a developer background it should be quite easy to get started. After the upgrade I felt a little frustrated by it, so decided to give Home Assistant (HASS) a try. In specific, this document helped inspire u/balloob to write Home Assistant the way he did Both Hubitat and Home Assistant have problems. sensors, WiFi, BT, and an RGB LED. They will often call out some "new, awesome feature" and totally downplay the fact that they removed X functionality and replaced it with some obscure, or totally omit the fact that they swapped out a giant portion of referenced code with a new version that breaks tons of things. Powered by a worldwide community of tinkerers and DIY enthusiasts. Both are compatible with a wide range of devices and applications, making them popular among users. But if you work with thousands of items and want to implement sophisticated automation rules, you can’t ignore Openhab. japhias (Jan) December 10, 2023, 1:43pm 1. Home Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Hi ! I’m the core maintainer of Gladys Assistant, an open-source smart home software that runs primarily on the Raspberry Pi. We installed used both smart home platforms for a year in four different houses to test and find a winner offering greater flexibility, better user interface and overall performance. Includes ambient light, humidity and temp. xml files seems to be like a sick joke to me 😉 Ah, well, the The great thing about Home-Assistant is that you can tied other systems into it so if I find there is something I can't do with Vera, I can use Home-Assistant as a secondary platform and tie between the 2 of them. OpenHab vs HomeSeer . It's good to hear it's not all happiness and rainbows on the Home Assistant side. Eg. home-assistant. Try linking a switch to a light in home assistant, you would need two items 5-10 lines of yaml each and then another 10 lines for linking them together. Supported devices and linking This subReddit is for DIY home automation enthusiasts, specifically those using the openHAB project (www. Reply. It tries to focus on simplicity (auto discover things when possible and/or feasible), a mobile first responsive and pretty user interface, and everything being modeled on the idea of an event bus. Home Assistant, we will look at exactly what Hubitat and Home Assistant are. 5 to 4, but instead set up a new instance and gradually move over. I’ve posted several time on this sub in the past years, and as we have made much progress in the past year, I wanted to get some feedback on our software from the community :) I am using OpenHab (2) and it works great. I don't know anything about openHab but I can tell you a little about how I use HA. Right now I'm in the process of migrating to home assistant. At the end of the post, you will have a clear picture of thebest option for your particular requi Dec 27, 2021 · Slowly and quietly, a new trend in smart homes is starting to take root among the ultra-techy. I switched because 1) I got a new zwave device (Aeotec siren) that was not supported in OpenHab. Jan 5, 2024 · Openhab is an open-source platform that allows you to connect and control a wide range of smart home devices. 2) because I really didn't like the way OpenHab 3 went, creating dashboard's was a pain and the dashboard you can make with HA (and HACS) are way nicer. Learning the OpenHAB internals is a fulltime job IMHO. Imagine having to leave the house and not being able to activate the home alarm due to errors in the sensors' integration Apr 6, 2023 · Before we look at some of the differences between Hubitat vs. Also, I assume that it does not require any special router configuration. Initially because OpenHab supported my zwave devices better, back then. I can only recommend it. Homekit integration is local (lan) of course. Python (Home Assistant) is a lot easier to figure out than Java (OpenHAB). As a Dev the rule language and configuration is easier in openhab. Hi, looking into an home automation software, I selected so far Openhab and Home That is when the different options here become a big plus. While things rarely break on Hubitat, due to slow downs, I try to keep custom programs off of Hubitat. Dec 10, 2023 · Comparison to Home Assistant. ntndz tqzds cznrsf wmdbl zrl kgkdl vjqqs zfsyw vxxy rtge